Category: Hot Trends: Developing Case Law
-
09.11.2019
No Attorneys’ Fees Awarded In Will Contest Where Case Had “Obvious Legal and Factual Weakness[es]”
In re the Estate of Connolly, No. A-3855-17T1, 2019 WL 1578804 (N.J. Super. Ct. App. Div. Apr. 12, 2019). This case involves a purported will drafted by an attorney who never met the decedent. The attorney drafted the will based on a telephone conversation he had with the decedent, who was then ninety (90) years […]
Read More -
09.11.2019
Litigant “Entitled to Fair and Reasonable Opportunity to Litigate”
De Paul vs. Estate of De Paul, A-0887-16t2, 2019 WL 1831554 (N.J. Super. Ct. App. Div. April 25, 2019). This action considered the reach of the entire controversy doctrine. The dispute stemmed from the disposition of a residential property in Mays Landing owned by the decedent, Catherine De Paul (“Catherine”). Catherine died testate in December […]
Read More -
07.12.2019
When the Complaint is Late, is Dismissal Appropriate?
IMO Estate of Lucy G. Kershak, Docket Nos. A-2897-17T3, A-4402-17T3, 2019 WL 1976066 (N.J. Super. Ct. App. Div. May 2, 2019) This case considers whether summary judgment is appropriate when a complaint opposing probate of a will is not timely filed. In 2008, the decedent executed a will prepared by her long-time attorney. The 2008 […]
Read More -
07.12.2019
Who Has Standing to Challenge Trustee’s Investments
In re Walker, 2019 PA Super 120, 2019 WL 1759792 (Pa. Super. Apr.22, 2019). This appeal deals with the standing for residual beneficiaries of a revocable trust. In July 2001, Pauline O. Walker (“decedent”) created a revocable trust, naming her daughters, Katherine W. Bantleon and Elizabeth W. Mecke (“the daughters”), as the residual beneficiaries. Smithfield […]
Read More -
07.12.2019
When a Refunding Bond is Required
In the Matter of the Estate of Dorothy Dreher, No. A-4800-17T3, 2019 WL 1512720 (N.J. Super. Ct. App. Div. April 8, 2019). Dorothy Dreher had two children, David and Rebecca. David was the executor. Rebecca filed a verified complaint to vacate the probate judgment on grounds of undue influence and lack of capacity. After four […]
Read More -
05.29.2019
Divorce Agreement Determines Estate Litigation Outcome
Allen v. Estate of Allen, No. A-2605-17TI, 2019 WL 150169 (N.J. Super. Ct. App. Div. Jan. 7, 2019). This unpublished Appellate Division case covers a number of estate litigation topics, including real estate title issues, rights among spouses, and constructive trusts. The facts of the case are relatively simple. In 1961, Norma Allen (“Norma”) and […]
Read More -
05.29.2019
The State of New Jersey Inherits, Second Cousins Don’t
In the Matter of the Estate of Rosenthal, No. P-461-18 (N.J. Super. Ct. Ch. Div., Mar. 6, 2019). Sally Rosenthal died intestate, with no spouse or children. After a genealogical search for the Sally’s family members, the investigator concluded that Sally’s only surviving relatives that could be found were second cousins and second cousins, once […]
Read More -
04.10.2019
The Doctrine of Standing and the Right to an Accounting in Pennsylvania
In the Matter of Nadzam, Deceased, 2019 PA. Super. 14 (Jan. 14, 2019). JoAnn Domitrovich and Mandy Burket were two of the six children of the decedent, Allen Nadzam (“the decedent”). The decedent died on July 1, 2017. Thereafter, JoAnn initiated an action with the Court of Common Pleas of Beaver County Orphans’ Court in […]
Read More -
04.10.2019
Supreme Court of Pennsylvania to Address Attorney-Client Privilege Between a Trustee and Counsel
In re Estate of McAleer, 2018 PA Super. 227, 194 A.3d 587 (2018), petition for allowance of appeal granted, 2019 WL 423074 (Pa., Feb. 4, 2019). The settlor’s son and trustee, William H. McAleer, was involved in extensive litigation with two stepsons of the settlor, who were beneficiaries of the trust. Upon an accounting by […]
Read More -
04.10.2019
NJ Appellate Division Determined Executor Was Permitted to Represent Estate at Oral Argument
In the Matter of the Estate of Paruta, No. A-3456-17T2, 2019 WL 92244 (N.J. Super. Ct. App. Div. Jan. 3, 2019). The testator died with no immediate family and a will that left bequests to charities and individuals, including the defendant bank employee. The bank’s Code of Conduct and Ethics prohibited employees from accepting bequests […]
Read More